09-14-2009 11:22 AM
Hello techies,
I am planning to implement an array of microphones for localization of sound. Is LabVIEW the best for this or does anybody know a better one??
I would appreciate it if anybody could help me with this.
thanks in advance !
09-14-2009 11:54 AM
Stream of consciousness alert.
My sense is that LabVIEW is not the BEST.
The best is probably an all-hardware solution. Very difficult to build, harder to debug, harder still to modify.
Introduce software, the next best is probably coded in machine language. Probably harder than all-hardware.
Next best is to use a low-level language such as C with custom routines optimized for your particular problem. Hard, but doable and not user-friendly.
Move to a higher level language such as C++, better UI, slightly worse performance.
Move to LabVIEW/Measurement Studio. Slightly worse overhead, great UI, relatively easy to modify and debug. Probably the only one that works on a reasonable budget/timeline.
99+% of applications would probably not need the performance (at least initially) beyond what LV can deliver. Even if you did, you'd be crazy not to start with the most straightforward.
My personal bias is towards Measurement Studio. I feel that it gives me the ability to get my hands dirty when necessary but maintain a very clean UI. With LV I feel that there is some overhead when interfacing with external code. If I already knew LV would I learn/buy Measurement Studio just for this application, almost certainly not.
Don't let perfection be the enemy of the very, very good. I say go with LV.
End stream of consciousness.
09-14-2009 01:00 PM
If you already own LabVIEW, then yes, it will do what you are trying to accomplish.
Although as Darin said, LabVIEW is a little pricy to use for only one project.
However, it is a great investment if you are going to use it for other projects as well.
09-14-2009 01:35 PM
09-14-2009 03:16 PM
yaa I already have labview in my university labs.
I plan to implement it for my masters thesis.
But, I am a fresher with LV. I think I'll have a hard time figuring out things unless veterans like you might wanna help.
P.S. about posting a new thread: I thought the old thread died. I will try to maintain my queries in a single thread from now on.