THis sounds like a weird problem!
If i understand you correctly, you say as long as you press on resistor, everything is fine!
If this understanding is correct, it sounds like you have a mechanical connection issue. Re-check ALL of your conncetions. Not only the resitor leads and tach leads but also the cables to your terminal block.
If checking and re-doing all of your connections does not help then you may have a bad teminal block. I have seen cracked traces act this way.
Ben