LabVIEW Idea Exchange

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
PJM_Labview

Icon Editor "Icon Text tab" Usability improvement

Status: New

I am proposing to improve the usability of the new LV 2009 Icon Editor "Icon Text" tab along these lines:

 

IE Icon Text Improvement.png

 

PJM



  


vipm.io | jki.net

8 Comments
ThSa
Active Participant

I really like that idea!

There is still the question though, whether we need a 5th line for the header or not.

 

 

What should we do with the space that is gonna be available on the icon text tab?

Not that I would complain about it, but the difference of the used space is incredible...

PJM_Labview
Active Participant

In my opinion, tab do not improve usability, so if we could get rid off this "Icon Text" tab this will be great.

 

The problem is that it is not obvious on which other tab it should be merged with (may be the "template" or "glyph" one?) [I think the template is the most likely candidate].

 

About a 5th (header) line, this could be done fairly easily by just adding one line to the string control (the software can keep track of the formatting used in each line).

 

PJM

 

 



  


vipm.io | jki.net

ThSa
Active Participant

I think that neither of the other tabs is a good candidate to host the icon text.

If the icon text is gonna be embedded in one of the other tabs (glyph or template), it might end up be too confusing whether the icon text can only be used in combination with glyphs or with templates.

PJM_Labview
Active Participant

Yes, I agree that moving this to any of the existing tab is not ideal (although is is somewhat related to template because the template define where the text goes).

 

Another possiblity, is to have this as a separate UI that would be called upon pressing a button (I am not sure I like this too much)...

 

Finally, another idea would be to do it like this (I think it works ok with the new design I have, but it could be adapted to the existing UI).

 

Note: The icon text could even have an extra line for header.

 

Improved IE with formatting toolbar 2.png



  


vipm.io | jki.net

muks
Proven Zealot
Will be a nice addition no doubt.
PJM_Labview
Active Participant

I gave this more though, and I think the new formatting should probably relocated on the template tab.

 

The resoning behind this is that in goes with the typical workflow of creating a new VI Icon which is as follow:

 

1) Select the template you want to use

2) Enter the text

3) more...

 

The tab could be renamed "Template & Icon Text"

 

I also agree that I want an extra line for the banner area.

 

 



  


vipm.io | jki.net

JackDunaway
Trusted Enthusiast
I think the Icon Editor UI is bloated, and out of principle I will Kudos this idea. I'm not particularly attached to this upgrade, but it is one among many that could increase the "usability density" of the Icon Editor. In other words: the same task is being completed with both user interfaces, but the upgrade contains common glyphs (no translation needed for localization!), and the upgrade takes up 1/4 the real estate.
Message Edited by mechelecengr on 08-17-2009 12:58 PM
AristosQueue (NI)
NI Employee (retired)

There is an update for the LV 2009 icon editor (posted Sept 14, 2009) available here:

http://decibel.ni.com/content/docs/DOC-6301

 

This update incorporates many suggestions that we got right off the bat from users and fixes a number of reported bugs.

 

An entire discussion forum exists for discussions about improving/extending the Icon Editor. It can be found here:

http://decibel.ni.com/content/groups/enhanced-icon-editor-2009