LabVIEW

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

DSC vs. TDM

Hi,


In our company we have a few data-loggers and are thinking of an improvement considering data-management and reusability. Therefore we consider the DSC (Citadel) and the TDM format.


At the moment we are looking per hour to a binary file with a size of 133 MB. We have 32 digital and 64 analog channels. Every channel creates 500 data points per second. Every value of the 32 digital channels (Boolean array) is converted into an U32 value.


I have already tested DSC and TDM. The data-management and the performance of viewing the data is very good with Citadel. Disadvantages: When writing the digital channels to the database every value reserves at least 1 Byte à overhead of at least 7 bits. The entire needed storage for one hour grows about factor 3. We’ve also tried to compress a digital array of 32 values to an U32 value. That would save storage but viewing the data with MAX isn’t possible. Therefore we have tried to programmatically view the data with the Mixed Signal Graph which would be a good opportunity for us to view analog and digital data. Unfortunately the loading of the data isn’t reasonable for our users. Furthermore we have also tried to use MAX to view data from a remote computer. There we detected a great performance lost compared with viewing on a local machine. Is it a know issue?


Next we’ve investigated the TDM format. It is really a great thing (we can store the scaling and other describing information) but a big problem for us is that we aren’t able to search within the binary data. A further disadvantage compared with DSC is that we have to care for the data management and that the viewing of the data is much slower.


Has anybody tips or details for a possible solution for our problem?


Many thanks in advance.


Kind Regards,


Joachim

0 Kudos
Message 1 of 4
(4,750 Views)

hello joachim,

did you try to browse your TDM data with the software DIAdem?
there you have a powerful search tool (datafinder), where you can search your data "google"-like or search for specific conditions.
you can find a eval-version here.

kind regards,

robert h
NI germany

0 Kudos
Message 2 of 4
(4,729 Views)
Hi Robert,

Yes, we already use Diadem in our company. The main problem is that we aren't able to search the binary data --> signal. In our binary file we have compressed 32 digital signals to an U32. There is only the possibilty to view the data with a DataPlugin which describes the configuration of the binary file. The TDM format is a good format but our application should be continous user friendly. Our favourite would be the TDM file format which can be viewed with the Mixed Signal Graph with a high performance like the MAX is doing it with Citadel data.

Kind Regards,

Joachim Schreibmaier
0 Kudos
Message 3 of 4
(4,724 Views)
What kind of data searching needs do you have?

p.s. Which company do you work for?
--
Tomi Maila
0 Kudos
Message 4 of 4
(4,715 Views)